Baby-Led Weaning vs. Traditional Weaning - Which Approach is Right for You?

Starting solids is a major milestone in your baby’s first year - but with it often comes a big question: how should you introduce those first foods?

Two popular methods are baby-led weaning (BLW) and traditional spoon-feeding. Each has its benefits, challenges, and passionate advocates. But the truth is, there’s no "perfect" way, only the way that feels right for your baby and your family.

In this guide, we’ll explore both approaches in depth, so you can choose the path (or blend) that works best for you.

What is Baby-Led Weaning?

Baby-led weaning is based on giving your baby soft, appropriately sized pieces of real food to self-feed from the very beginning of their weaning journey.

Instead of spoon-feeding purees, babies are offered whole foods they can grasp and explore like a steamed broccoli floret, a slice of soft avocado, or a wedge of roasted sweet potato.

The philosophy behind baby-led weaning centres on trusting your baby’s instincts:

allowing them to decide how much to eat, how fast to eat, and how they interact with food. It respects babies as capable little eaters from the start.

Benefits of Baby-Led Weaning

• Encourages independence: Babies learn to self-feed and listen to their internal hunger and fullness cues.

• Supports motor skill development: Picking up food helps fine motor skills and hand-eye coordination.

• Introduces a wide variety of textures: Early exposure to different food textures can support oral and sensory development.

• Involves babies in family meals: Baby eats what the family eats (with modifications for safety), building social eating habits early.

Many parents find that BLW makes mealtimes more relaxed and enjoyable, encouraging babies to be curious about food rather than pressured.

Challenges of Baby-Led Weaning

• Messier mealtimes: Learning through exploration means food gets squished, thrown, and dropped.

• Concerns about intake: Parents may worry whether their baby is eating enough, especially in the early stages.

• Gagging (not choking): Gagging is common and expected as babies learn to manage real textures, but it can be unsettling to watch.

Close supervision and offering soft, appropriately sized foods is essential for safety during baby-led weaning.

What is Traditional Weaning?

Traditional weaning follows a more structured path:You begin by spoon-feeding your baby smooth purees, gradually moving to thicker consistencies, mashed foods, and eventually finger foods as your baby’s skills develop.

Parents have more control over what and how much their baby eats initially, which can feel reassuring, particularly if there are concerns about allergies, reflux, or slow weight gain.

Benefits of Traditional Weaning

• Easier to monitor intake: You can more easily see what your baby has consumed at each meal.

• Smoother transition for some babies: Babies who prefer predictable textures may find purees comforting at the start.

• Gradual introduction to different textures: Starting with purees can ease the adjustment to solids for some families.

Challenges of Traditional Weaning

• Potential delay in chewing skills: Some babies may become reliant on purees and take longer to transition to textured foods if not introduced early enough.

• Less opportunity for self-feeding: Babies may become passive at mealtimes if not given chances to explore independently.

• Can be more time-intensive: Preparing different purees and separate meals for baby and family can be more labour-intensive.

Which Weaning Approach is Right for You?

There’s no right or wrong method - only what feels aligned with your baby’s needs, your intuition, and your lifestyle.

Baby-led weaning may suit you if:

• You want your baby to explore a wide range of textures early.

• You enjoy sharing family meals together.

• You’re comfortable with a bit more mess and a hands-off approach.

Traditional weaning may suit you if:

• You prefer structured meal planning and monitoring intake.

• Your baby has specific feeding needs (such as reflux or allergies).

• You find reassurance in a gradual, spoon-fed introduction.

Many families naturally blend both approaches — offering purees alongside soft finger foods, depending on the meal, the day, and the baby’s interest. Flexibility is often the key.

Key Tips for Safe and Successful Weaning (Whichever Path You Choose)

• Always supervise your baby while eating.

• Offer foods in safe shapes and sizes (long finger shapes, soft textures).

• Avoid foods that pose choking hazards (whole grapes, raw apples, hard nuts).

• Sit your baby upright in a secure highchair at every meal.

• Trust your baby's instincts: they know when they’re full or need a break.

• Make mealtimes calm, unhurried, and positive.

Common Myths About Weaning — Gently Debunked

"My baby needs teeth before starting solids."Not true. Babies can gum soft foods effectively. Teeth are not necessary to begin weaning.

"Gagging means my baby is choking."Gagging is a natural protective reflex as babies learn to move food around their mouth. Choking is rare when foods are appropriately prepared and supervision is consistent.

"If I don’t spoon-feed, my baby won’t get enough nutrition."With appropriate food choices and continued milk feeds, babies regulate their own intake remarkably well, whether fed by spoon or hand.

Choosing a weaning approach isn’t about doing it perfectly. It’s about creating a safe, supported environment where your baby can explore food with curiosity and joy.

Some days will be messy. Some meals will be tiny bites. Some will be big victories. All of it is part of the process.

Trust your baby. Trust yourself. You’re doing better than you think.

🌿 For more practical weaning tips, simple meal ideas, and real motherhood support, download the free Carol App today on IOS and Android.

🌿 And if you're ready to feel more grounded in yourself during this big season of change, explore The Calm Mum Formula — available now on a Pay-What-Feels-Right basis.